More of the same?

2012-09-01

What’s wrong with Google+ on Android…?

Filed under: FAIL, Miscellaneous, Mobile, Software — _ds_ @ 02:45

What I don’t like about the ‘new’ +Google+ UI, having just upgraded downgraded from the last version for Android which supported Incoming (due to them finally having switched it off):

  • Circles menu is… inconvenient.
    • Being able to select which circles are shown there is useful, particularly if you have many. Alternatively, being able to mark some as ‘important’ (regarding placement in that menu) would work – and I include the pseudo-circles in this.
  • Pictures and videos are initially confusing, being above the name and posting text.
    • In portrait mode, they look like they’re associated with the content immediately above.
    • In landscape mode, the avatar and name appear misplaced.
    • The avatar shouldn’t overlap them – as is, it looks bad. I’d put it, name, date etc. above.
  • The avatar looks bad.
    • It should match desktop browser G+, i.e. not clipped to a circle.
  • In landscape mode:
    • Posting arrangement is strange. Should be vertical.
    • Notifications are badly placed. I didn’t find them until I saw the side menu in portrait mode.
    • Viewing a single thread makes bad use of the available space.
      • Here, it’s restricted in width to the height of the display (more or less). It needs to use the full width of the display (which, here, is 800×480).
    • Adding a comment doesn’t work well.
      • This is due to the above thread view limitation.
      • Portrait mode is better for display reasons, but this makes soft keyboard rather more awkward (narrow buttons).
      • Strangely, given this, making a new posting works as well as it previously did in landscape mode.
  • Nothing to indicate that there’s more text in a posting (in the stream view).
  • Still no indication of struck-through text.
  • No scroll bar in the stream view? Weird.
  • ‘Swipe to switch circles’ is missing.
  • ‘What’s Not’ is present.
  • Incoming is missing (but I expected that).
    • I don’t expect to go through each and every ‘not yet in circles’ profile to see what’s there – that’s what Incoming’s for.

The UI in the last version for Android to support Incoming works. It’s nice and clean. This one’s… less clean.

I’ve reported most of this little lot via the G+ feedback page (in smaller chunks due to the paltry 500-character limit). Hopefully we’ll see some improvements, including the return of Incoming. But somehow I think that that’s not going to happen…

Finally, according to the ‘city-level’ location, I’m in Northern Europe. While technically true, it often makes attaching my location rather less than useful.

Blog at WordPress.com.